The Luminous, Hard State Can’t Be MAD

Colloquium

Speaker

  • P. Chris Fragile

When

  • – ET

Where

162 Fifth Avenue, 5th Floor Classroom

160 Fifth Avenue

New York, NY 10010

Abstract

I will present a straightforward argument for why the luminous, hard state of black hole X-ray binaries (BHXRBs) cannot always be associated with a magnetically arrested accretion disc (MAD). This is significant as MADs are often invoked to explain the hard state and are becoming the preferred model by many numericists. My argument relies on three core premises: (1) that the type-C quasi-periodic oscillation (QPO) is best explained by Lense–Thirring (LT) precession of a tilted, inner, hot flow; (2) that observed optical and infrared (IR) QPOs with the same or lower frequency as the type-C QPO suggest the jet, too, must precess in these systems; and (3) that numerical simulations of MADs show that their strong magnetic fields promote alignment of the disc with the black hole and, thereby, suppress LT precession. In my talk, I will present supporting evidence for all three premises. In the end, if we accept them all as true, then, at least whenever the optical and IR QPOs are observed alongside the type-C QPO, these systems cannot be in the MAD state. Extending the argument further, if the type-C QPO is always associated with LT precession, then it would rule out MADs anytime this timing feature is seen, which covers nearly all BHXRBs when they are in the luminous, hard and hard-intermediate states. At the end of my talk, I will discuss possible alternatives to my conclusions.

P. Chris Fragile: The Luminous, Hard State Can’t be MAD
A red, wireframe, spherical shape with wavy edges is centered on a light beige background, resembling a 3D mesh or abstract digital sculpture.

Event Series

CCA Colloquium

A weekly forum in computational astrophysics

Guest lectures on forefront astrophysical research topics aimed at non-expert professional physicists.

See events

More Events

November 19, 2026

11 a.m.–12 p.m. ET

Speaker

Andrea Califano, Ph.D.

Computational Astrophysics

Fast Radio Bursts

Colloquium

December 1, 2026

3–4 p.m. ET

Speaker

Vicky Kaspi

December 11, 2026

3–4 p.m. ET

Speaker

Kyle Kremer